I got a email from a client asking for help because Excel was “destroying,” to use his terminology, his 2003 workbook after conversion to the 2007 format. And, after analyzing the kind of change Excel made, I had to agree.
The following in 2003
Figure 1
becomes, in 2013 (and in 2010),
Figure 2
The basic problem is that names that are legitimate names in Excel 2003 may become unacceptable in 2007 (or later). But, a more devastating problem is with a formula using a name with a dot in it. Even though it is completely legitimate, Excel changes the dot to a colon. This causes the formula =SW1.SW2 to become =SW1:SW2. Don’t ask me why. It just does. The result is the formula is all wrong and destroys the integrity of the workbook.
It appears that the cause may be Excel trying to help manage the transition of a XLS workbook into the newer format. In 2007, Microsoft increased the number of columns from 256 to 16,384. Consequently, the reference to last column went from IV to XFD. So, a name such as SW1, completely OK in 2003, became unacceptable in 2007. On converting a XLS file to a XLSX file, Excel will convert such names by adding an underscore at the start of the name. But, it seems to go beyond that, converting formula references to certain names with dots in them to a colon. This happens if both the tokens to the left and to the right of the dot could be legitimate cell references. So, Excel converts the formula =XFD1.XFD2 to =XFD1:XFD2 but it will leave =XFD1.XFE2 alone.
To replicate the problem:
- Start with Excel 2003. Create a workbook and add the names shown in the Figure 1. Save and close the workbook.
- Open the workbook in Excel 2013. Save it as a XLSX file. Acknowledge the warning message (see Figure 3),
Figure 3
- Close and reopen the new XLSX workbook. The formulas will have the errors shown in Figure 2.
The safest way to work around this problem is to add an underscore before every name in the workbook before making the transition to the 2007 format. Obviously, the quickest way to do this would be with a very simple VBA procedure. But, through trial and error I discovered the code will not work in 2003. It runs without any problems but it doesn’t do anything!
So, the correct way to use the code is the following sequence.
- Open the XLS file in 2013 (or 2010).
- Run the macro below.
|
|
Option Explicit Sub fixNames() Dim aName As Name For Each aName In ActiveWorkbook.Names With aName If Left(.Name, 1) <> "_" Then _ .Name = "_" & .Name End With Next aName End Sub |
- Now, save the file in the newer format. If your original workbook had no code in it, save the file as a XLSX file and acknowledge the warning that the VB project will be lost.
- Close and reopen the file. You should see the correct data with all the names now starting with an underscore.
Figure 4
Tushar Mehta
TM Goal Seek enhances the existing user interface to Excel’s Goal Seek feature. The built in Goal Seek is a simple optimization tool that suffices for a large number of scenarios. The UI, unfortunately, is extremely unwieldy and unfriendly. TM Goal Seek is a simple add-in that is easier to use than the default dialog box because of three critical benefits:
