Over on Swimming Splits, Olly asks:
I am a rowing coach and am putting the data that my crew gives me from their training sessions into a spreadsheet in the mm:ss.00 format. However, if I make a mistake inputting the data e.g type 1:23.03 when it should be 1:23.30 something weird happens.
When I click in the cell, the value rounds up or down depending so 1:23.30 will round to 1:23.00. This will have a massive impact on the results that I am looking at. Is this a common occurrence in excel or is there something that I am doing wrong or should be pressing?
Good question. I’m not sure that I know this answer definitively, but I’ll tell you what I think based on what I see.
Dates and times are strange beasts in Excel. I should say that they are a strange beast because they are the same thing. As you probably already know, dates are stored as the number of days from a particular date, usually 31-Dec-1899. That means that 01-Jan-1900 is stored as 1 and 04-March-2007 is stored as 39,145. Similarly, times are stored as fractions of a day. While dates are integers, times of day are the fractions between the integers. Today may be 39,145, but today at 8:00AM is 39145.3333333. It’s only 8:00AM and already a third of the day is gone.
This method is great for adding, subtracting, and generally doing other math operations on dates. What it’s not good for is understandability by most humans. Excel attempts to bridge that gap by displaying dates and times as dates and times rather than these cryptic numbers. Note that when you enter
in a cell, the formula bar displays
Usually the formula bar will tell you the truth regardless of how you’ve formatted the cells, but not in the case of dates and times. Like an over-protective mother, it shields you from the harsh realities. The noteworthy aspect of this example is that there are no hundredths in the formula bar. The hundredths are still stored, but they aren’t displayed in the formula bar.
If you were to edit the cell, say, by pressing F2 and Enter you lose the hundredths. Pressing Enter is the same as entering
into the cell, which contains no hundredths. To change the cell from 3 hundredths to 3 tenths, follow these steps: F2 to edit the cell, backspace three times to remove the AM and the preceding space, type .3, press Enter. I don’t know of any way to get the hundredths to display in the formula bar.
It seems rather easy for Microsoft to have done this differently. If a user enters fractions of seconds, display fractions of seconds. Otherwise display it as it is now. There doesn’t seem to be a trade-off here that I can see (other than coding time by developers).